The Sweetest Lobster: A Comprehensive Guide to Maine vs. Rock Lobster

Lobster lovers, rejoice! This guide delves into the world of two popular lobster varieties: Maine and Rock, helping you determine which one reigns supreme in the sweetness department.

Maine Lobster: The Sweetheart of the Sea

Hailing from the chilly waters of the North Atlantic, Maine lobsters are renowned for their unparalleled sweetness. Their delicate, buttery flavor and succulent texture make them a true culinary delight.

Why Maine Lobsters are Sweeter:

  • Cold Water Habitat: The cold waters of the North Atlantic contribute to the lobster’s slower growth rate, resulting in a more concentrated and refined sweetness.
  • Natural Diet: Maine lobsters feast on a diverse array of crustaceans, fish, and seaweed, contributing to their rich and complex flavor profile.
  • High Meat-to-Shell Ratio: Compared to rock lobsters, Maine lobsters boast a higher meat-to-shell ratio, meaning more succulent, sweet flesh to savor.

Rock Lobster: A Briny Bite from the Tropics

Found in warmer waters around the globe, rock lobsters offer a distinct flavor profile compared to their Maine counterparts. Their meat is firmer and grainier, with a more pronounced brininess.

Why Rock Lobsters are Less Sweet:

  • Warm Water Habitat: The warmer waters where rock lobsters reside contribute to a faster growth rate, resulting in a less concentrated sweetness.
  • Different Diet: Rock lobsters primarily consume mollusks and sea urchins, leading to a more subtle and briny flavor.
  • Lower Meat-to-Shell Ratio: Rock lobsters have a lower meat-to-shell ratio, meaning less sweet flesh compared to Maine lobsters.

The Verdict: Maine Lobster Takes the Sweetness Crown

While both Maine and Rock lobsters offer unique culinary experiences, Maine lobsters emerge as the undisputed champion of sweetness. Their delicate, buttery flavor, succulent texture, and higher meat-to-shell ratio make them the ideal choice for those seeking a truly sweet and satisfying lobster experience.

Additional Considerations:

  • Cooking Methods: Both Maine and Rock lobsters can be cooked in various ways, including steaming, grilling, and boiling. However, the delicate flavor of Maine lobster is best enjoyed with minimal seasoning, allowing its natural sweetness to shine.
  • Availability and Price: Maine lobsters are generally more readily available and affordable compared to Rock lobsters.
  • Personal Preference: Ultimately, the best lobster for you depends on your personal taste preferences. If you prioritize sweetness and a delicate texture, Maine lobster is the way to go. If you prefer a firmer texture and a more pronounced brininess, Rock lobster might be your ideal choice.

Enjoy the Sweetness of Maine Lobster!

For a truly sweet and unforgettable lobster experience, look no further than the Maine lobster. Its delicate flavor, succulent texture, and high meat-to-shell ratio make it the perfect choice for discerning seafood lovers. So, indulge in the sweetness of Maine lobster and savor every delicious bite!

Hard shell Maine lobster

If you order lobster at a restaurant or pluck one out of a supermarkets tank in most of the United States, chances are youre getting a hard shell Maine lobster. The Maine lobster itself is technically the same species as the soft shell Maine lobster and the Canadian lobster, but various conditions make it unique (via The Ocean Mart). The Maine Lobster is found in the North Atlantic, off the east coast of the United States, with the highest concentrations being close to New England and Maine specifically, hence the name.

The Maine lobster itself is smaller than the similar Canadian lobster, due to the slightly warmer waters it inhabits. Although its smaller, the meat tends to be sweeter, which balances things out somewhat. The “hard shell” part of the name refers to the length of time since the lobster last molted. Hard shell lobsters are usually fished between fall and spring. They tend to have around 20% more meat in their shells than soft shell lobsters, and are also more durable. That means hard shell lobsters can be transported further and kept alive longer than soft shell lobsters. So if you live away from the coast and see fresh lobsters in a local restaurant, you can bet theyre the hard shell version. Unlike the more delicate soft shell lobsters, hard shells are durable enough to be grilled — so you should consider buying a few if youre a fan of seafood BBQs (via Lobster Anywhere).

Soft shell Maine lobster

The soft shell variant of the Maine (or American) lobster is the exact same species as the hard shell, except it has molted more recently and its exoskeleton is still in the hardening process (via The Ocean Mart). Soft shell lobsters are usually caught in the summer months, and are not as durable as hard-shell lobsters. As a result, transporting them away from the coastal areas they are caught in is extremely difficult. This means that they are extremely abundant in places like coastal Maine, and they tend to be cheaper as a result.

Because their new shell contains a lot of growing room, youll find less meat inside a soft shell lobster than you would a hard shell of the same weight. However, because the space that would be meat is taken up by water, you can expect extra tender lobste,r as the water within the lobster marinates the meat while cooking (via Wholesale Maine Lobster). For the best results, consider boiling your soft shell lobster in salt water, as this process will not damage the delicate meat. Lobster Anywhere provides instructions on the amount of salt to add and the time you need to boil your lobster. If you want to liven the dish up a bit, consider creating a traditional New England lobster roll by coating chunks of lobster meat in mayonnaise and adding them to a butter toasted hot dog bun.

Like the Maine lobster, the Canadian lobster is also of the genus Homarus americanus, meaning theyre the exact same species (via The Ocean Mart). However, the colder waters off the Canadian coast produce lobsters that are different enough to gain their own distinction.

Compared to their counterparts south of the border, Canadian lobsters are typically larger and less sweet. Additionally, Canadian lobsters typically have denser meat and shells. Though the differences aren’t that great, “Canadian lobster” tends to be less expensive per pound because it’s not as well-known as “Maine lobster,” so lovers of lobster may be able to score a deal.

The thick shells and dense meat of Canadian lobsters make them suitable for more aggressive cooking techniques. A Canadian lobster might be the best option if you want to try baking or grilling lobster and are searching for a more accommodating variety that has less financial repercussions if you make a mistake.

Homarus gammarus is a unique species of lobster found in the seas surrounding Europe. It is also referred to as the European lobster, French blue, or common lobster. The Atlantic, North, Irish, Mediterranean, and Baltic seas are among them. The European lobster is commonly blue in color, unlike its American cousin, but when cooked, it turns brick red.

The European lobster also tends to be smaller than Homarus americanus, but the quantity is offset by quality, as the meat tends to be more flavorful. As lobsters dont tend to travel well, it is nearly impossible to get live European lobster in North America, and frozen French Blues come at a premium. The European lobster spends its time on the sea floor subsisting on small fishes, crustaceans, and shellfish, which all contribute to its fantastic flavor. It is best boiled, but can be baked, barbecued, steamed, or boiled and eaten hot or cold (via Mmmediterranean).

Like other warm water lobsters (and contrary to their cold water equivalents), the Florida spiny lobster lacks claws (via the Gates Hotel). However, it makes up for this by providing plenty of delicious tail meat. The meats flavor isnt as sweet or delicate as the kind youll find under a Maine lobsters shell, but it still tastes great and pairs well with a variety of dishes, from pasta to soup to omlettes to gumbo. The flavor has been described as similar to crawfish.

The Florida spiny lobster, sometimes referred to as the Caribbean lobster, is frequently found on menus from Key West to Kingston. This lobsters habitat ranges from South Carolina to Brazil. This type of fresh lobster is typically available in Florida for about eight months out of the year.

According to this fish, the color of Caribbean or Florida lobsters can range from olive green to brown prior to cooking. Additionally, their abdomens have yellow spots on them.

Also known as the Norwegian lobster or Dublin Bay prawn, this small species is popular in cuisines across Europe (via Great British Chefs). One of the more well-known dishes the langoustine crops up in is traditional scampi, though this tends to cost significantly more than the versions that use fish or shrimp. Langoustine season runs from September to May, and the most common fisheries are in the North Sea, close to Norway, Scotland, and off the north east coast of England.

Langoustines tend to be firmer and sweeter than larger lobster species, and they dont have to stand alone in a dish. The late, great Keith Floyd used langoustines alongside monkfish and bass, in what he described as “the best fish stew in the world.” Most langoustines available in North America will be frozen, but if you have an opportunity to buy fresh langoustines you should be on the lookout for dark black eyes, lively movements, and no signs of damage to the antennae, legs, or shell.

Like the Caribbean lobster, the California lobster is a warm water species and lacks claws (via Vice). However, unlike its East Coast cousin, the California lobster rarely finds itself on a Western plate. Described as “slightly chewy” and as having a “creamy and extremely nutty flavor,” the California spiny lobster might just be the West Coast scuba diving communitys best-kept secret, as theyre the only Americans that have access to them. However, they are quite popular in China, which is where the majority of commercially caught spiny lobsters from California and Mexico end up.

Scripps Institution of Oceanography graduate Kate Masury claims the Chinese prefer clawless lobster species to their cold water counterparts. This demand has driven up the price of the lobsters, leading Americans to select cheaper options. Still, if you manage to get your hands on a California spiny lobster, you may want to treat yourself by boiling them, dousing them with butter, slapping them on a hot grill for a few minutes, and then finishing with even more butter (via OC Wild Seafood).

Not all European lobsters have claws. The Mediterranean lobster (Palinurus elephas) is another type of clawless warm water lobster that isn’t very common worldwide but can be seen if you regularly visit coastal markets in Southern Europe.

Contrary to its name, the Mediterranean lobster can be found as far away as the coasts of Great Britain and Ireland. The crustacean has become a bit harder to source after being identified as “vulnerable” by the IUCN in 2013. Recovery efforts have included fishing restrictions and restocking attempts. One of the more promising actions has involved restocking areas where fishing is prohibited with below-legal size lobsters. Within the first few years, this tactic resulted in the “catch per unit effort (CPUE)” of the prohibited areas showing an estimated 300% to 700% increase in “both density and biomass burst” (via The increase in biomass also spilled over into areas where fishing was allowed, with regular fisheries showing a “30–50% increase in density and biomass CPUE.”

A traditional rock lobster recipe from the area involves boiling and halving the lobsters before covering them in an oil, lemon juice, and salt, dressing (via SBS).

LOBSTER TASTE TEST! How to Cook Lobster! Which one is the best?!?!?!?


What is considered the best tasting lobster?

While warm water lobsters have their own unique qualities and are enjoyed by locals in various regions, Maine lobsters remain unrivaled in their size, meatiness, and flavor. Their cold-water environment gives them a distinctive taste and texture that has made them a beloved delicacy around the world.

What is the most delicious type of lobster?

Lobsters from Maine have gained a reputation for being the best lobsters in the world. Not only they have juicy claw meat, but their tail meat is also extremely firm. If you want to enjoy “true” lobsters, you must buy this type.

What is the most delicious lobster in the world?

Maine Lobster is the sweetest, most flavorful and tender lobster you can eat. Hand-caught by a community of lobstermen committed to sustainable fishing for generations. If it’s not from Maine—it’s not lobster.

Which lobster tail is sweet?

Maine lobster tails are world renown for their sweet and delicate taste while also having a lot of meat in one shell.

What is the best type of lobster?

The “best” type of lobster often comes down to personal preference. For those who cherish the classic lobster claw meat, cold water varieties like the Maine lobster are the go-to choice. For others, the unique flavors and textures of warm water lobster tails might be more appealing.

Is lobster high in low-density lipoprotein (LDL)?

Lobster is low in saturated fatty acids and rich in omega-3 fatty acids which are good for the heart and help lower cholesterol.

What does lobster taste like?

If you’re a big fan of nutritious seafood, you may have known thoroughly the flavor of all existing types of shrimp and crab! The flavor of lobster is depicted as a delicate cross between these two crustaceans, without a doubt. The firmness, smoothness, and softness of the meat all show up in one bite.

What kind of lobster is in Florida?

Also known as the Caribbean lobster, the Florida spiny lobster is a common sight on menus from Key West to Kingston. This lobster’s habitat ranges from South Carolina to Brazil. Fresh lobster of this variety tends to be available in Florida for around eight months per year.

Leave a Comment