Spinach and paneer, two culinary staples in Indian cuisine, have long been enjoyed for their distinct flavors and textures. However, recent nutritional insights have shed light on a potential concern surrounding this popular combination. This article delves into the scientific evidence to explore why spinach and paneer may not be the ideal pairing for optimal nutrient absorption.
The Calcium-Iron Conundrum
At the heart of the nutritional concern lies the interaction between calcium and iron. Spinach is renowned for its richness in iron, an essential mineral for oxygen transport and red blood cell production. Paneer, on the other hand, is a good source of calcium, a crucial mineral for strong bones and teeth.
However, when consumed together, calcium can interfere with the absorption of non-heme iron, the type of iron found in plant-based foods like spinach. This occurs because calcium binds to iron in the digestive tract, forming insoluble compounds that cannot be absorbed by the body.
The Impact on Iron Absorption
Studies have demonstrated that consuming calcium-rich foods along with non-heme iron sources can significantly reduce iron absorption. One study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, found that consuming 100 mg of calcium with a meal containing non-heme iron reduced iron absorption by approximately 50%.
This reduction in iron absorption can have implications for individuals with iron deficiency or those at risk of developing iron deficiency, such as pregnant women, children, and vegetarians. Iron deficiency can lead to fatigue, weakness, and impaired cognitive function.
Alternative Iron Sources
While spinach and paneer may not be the most effective combination for iron absorption, there are numerous other plant-based foods that are excellent sources of non-heme iron. These include:
- Lentils
- Beans
- Tofu
- Tempeh
- Fortified cereals
Maximizing Iron Absorption
To maximize iron absorption from plant-based foods, it is recommended to:
- Consume iron-rich foods with vitamin C-rich foods, such as citrus fruits or tomatoes. Vitamin C enhances iron absorption.
- Avoid consuming calcium-rich foods, such as dairy products or leafy green vegetables, at the same time as iron-rich foods.
- Cook iron-rich foods in cast iron cookware. Cast iron leaches iron into food during cooking.
While spinach and paneer are both nutritious foods, their combination may not be optimal for iron absorption due to the inhibitory effect of calcium on iron. Individuals who are concerned about iron deficiency or who have a high need for iron are advised to consume iron-rich foods separately from calcium-rich foods and to incorporate other iron-rich sources into their diet. By following these recommendations, you can ensure that you are getting the essential nutrients your body needs for optimal health and well-being.
Palak Paneer is the most relished delicacy in India however, a nutritionist claims that these two food items should not be consumed together. Know what nutritionist Nmami Agarwal explains.
Although Palak Paneer is one of the most well-liked and well-known dishes in India, this may not be the best meal combination. Yes, you read correctly. While both paneer and palak are nutritious food options, this may come as a bit of a shock. Nutritionist Nmami Agarwal says eating paneer and palak together may not be as healthful as it seems. Nmami posted a video on her Instagram account outlining the reasons why the combination is unhealthy.
She shared the reel and stated, “Some combinations don’t work well together.” Healthy eating doesnt mean just eating the right food items. It refers to consuming the appropriate foods in the appropriate amounts. The nutritionist claims that paneer and palak together can cancel out each other’s advantages and are generally not a good combination. She describes why combining these two foods is unhealthy. She continues, “When eaten together, there are some combinations that inhibit the absorption of nutrients from one another.” One such combination is iron and calcium. Iron is abundant in spinach, and calcium is abundant in paneer. Calcium inhibits the absorption of iron!”.
Protein and calcium abound in paneer, which is beneficial to diabetics. Additionally, spinach, a leafy green vegetable, is a rich source of nutrients that can help prevent skin cancer, including iron, folic acid, vitamins A, E, and K, as well as omega-3 fatty acids. When eaten together, the paneer’s calcium limits spinach’s ability to absorb iron. Since the body can only absorb less than 5% of the iron found in spinach, it provides comparatively little iron to our bodies. High levels of oxalate, an antinutrient molecule, prevent the body from absorbing calcium and cause very little iron to be absorbed.
Even in Ayurveda, there is a concept known as Viruddha Ahaar that clarifies why some foods are not meant to be eaten together. A few pairings are also regarded as Viruddha Ahara, including curd and cheese, fish and milk, banana and milk, and honey and ghee in equal amounts.
Notice: The advice and recommendations in this article are meant only as general information and should not be construed as expert medical advice. Before beginning any exercise program or following any medical advice, please see a doctor.
Why Nutritionist claims Palak Paneer is Bad Food Combonation ?
FAQ
Can we eat spinach and paneer together?
Can we eat spinach and cottage cheese together?
Can I eat spinach with cheese?
What is best to eat with Palak paneer?
Are spinach and paneer a healthy combination?
She explains how spinach and paneer are not a healthy combination. She elaborates, “There are certain combinations that inhibit the nutrient absorption of each other when eaten together. One such combination is iron and calcium. Spinach is rich in iron and paneer is rich in calcium. Calcium inhibits the absorption of iron!”
How does one eat spinach?
Spinach can be eaten raw, sautéed, in salads, in pies, with fruit juice, in omelets, in soups and broths, and as your creativity allows.
How to cook spinach in a paneer?
Add 1-2 green chilies with the garlic if you like heat. Pan-fried paneer: For more flavor and a golden exterior on your paneer, quickly pan-fry it on medium heat in a bit of ghee or a combination of butter and oil. Having the right tools makes the cooking process smoother: Food Processor or Blender: Essential for pureeing the spinach.
What to eat with spinach & paneer Curry?
Steamed rice will taste wonderful with this Indian spinach and paneer curry (I like to use sona masoori rice or ambe mohar rice), but the best combination is palak paneer with jeera rice (cumin fried rice). The aroma of the cumin seeds and ghee is unbeatable. Palak paneer and naan is true restaurant-style food.