The Great Texas Chili Debate: Beans or No Beans?

Chili, a hearty and flavorful dish, is a staple in many households, especially during colder months. However, when it comes to the ingredients, there’s a long-standing debate: beans or no beans? In Texas, the answer is a resounding “no beans!”

The Tradition of Texas Chili: Meat, Sauce, and Spices

Texans take their chili seriously, and their version is distinct from other chili variations. It’s all about simplicity, focusing on the essential elements: meat, sauce, peppers, and spices. Beans are considered an unwelcome addition, diluting the pure flavor of the chili.

The International Chili Society, a non-profit organization dedicated to promoting and preserving the art of chili cooking, upholds this tradition. Their official chili recipe excludes beans, emphasizing the importance of showcasing the true essence of chili.

Historical Roots of the No-Bean Rule

The origins of the no-bean rule in Texas chili can be traced back to several factors:

  • Chili Queens: In the mid-19th century, San Antonio’s “Chili Queens” specialized in a meat-based dish called “Chili Con Carne,” which translates to “chili with meat.” Beans were typically served as a side dish, not included in the chili itself.
  • Cowboy Culture: During cattle drives, chili became a staple food in chuck wagons. Beans were often added to the chili, but the first official chili cook-off in 1952 at the State Fair of Texas excluded beans from the competition, solidifying the no-bean tradition in Texas chili.
  • Preserving Pure Chili Flavor: According to chili experts, beans can overpower the other flavors in the chili, masking the unique blend of spices and peppers. By omitting beans, the focus remains on the true essence of chili.

The Legacy of Kent Finlay and “Chili Has No Beans”

Kent Finlay, a beloved Texas singer and songwriter, passionately defended the no-bean tradition in his song “If you know Beans about Chili… you know Chili has no Beans.” He argued that true Texas chili is a meat-based dish, distinct from its Mexican origins, and that beans have no place in it.

The Modern Debate: To Bean or Not to Bean?

While the no-bean tradition remains strong in Texas, the debate continues. Some argue that beans add texture, flavor, and nutritional value to chili, making it a more complete and satisfying meal. Others maintain that beans detract from the traditional Texas chili experience.

Ultimately, the decision to add beans to chili is a personal one. If you’re looking for an authentic Texas chili experience, stick to the no-bean tradition. However, if you prefer a more hearty and flavorful chili, feel free to add beans to your liking.

The debate over beans in Texas chili is a testament to the diverse culinary landscape and the passionate opinions surrounding this iconic dish. Whether you prefer it with or without beans, there’s no denying that Texas chili is a unique and flavorful culinary tradition worth exploring.

The “Chili Queens,” women who served food in San Antonio’s Military Plaza as early as the 1860s, are credited with bringing chili con carne to America. In Galveston and Houston, chili stands were also prevalent; they were the 1800s equivalent of taco trucks. The most popular order was tamales with chili, frequently with beans added. Laborers counted on the chili vendors for a quick meal. Adventurous eaters loved them. And the affluent classes attempted to drive them out or shut them down.

Truck Stop Enchiladas (from The Tex-Mex Cookbook) At the Texas Grill, a vintage roadside cafe on Highway 90A in Rosenberg, I had a plate of cheese enchiladas in chili con carne that looked like this. They were topped with cheddar and sprinkled with raw onions.

Three pounds of chopped, quarter-inch-thick beef brisket; one pound of bacon; one and a half tablespoons of ground cumin; three and a half tablespoons of chili powder; two teaspoons of paprika; one teaspoon of dried oregano; one teaspoon of black pepper; half a teaspoon of dried thyme leaves; one and a half teaspoons of salt; four large, minced garlic cloves; one thirteen Two dried chipotle peppers and a 75-ounce can of beef broth or a 28-ounce can of puréed plum tomatoes

Here’s a fancier version of chili à la carte with bacon and chipotles. It is delicious on its own, over tamales, as an enchilada sauce for Truck Stop Enchiladas, or with a side order of beans.

In a large skillet, cook the bacon until crisp. Remove the bacon and reserve. Brown the beef in the remaining bacon drippings in the skillet over high heat, then set the meat aside. Saute the onions in the remaining drippings over medium heat for 8 to 10 minutes, or until they are lightly browned.

Many people take chili very seriously, especially when the weather cools off. However, Texans are quite particular about the ingredients they use in the filling dish.

Therefore, unless you’re competing (even in Texas!), it really doesn’t matter if you have beans or not. If you prefer to follow the conventional path, choose no beans. However, I won’t judge you if you want to indulge your inner cowboy by putting those beans in there. And to go with it, if you’re feeling really wild, prepare some delicious cinnamon rolls.

The answer is yes. Perhaps I’ve watched too many Westerns, but didn’t cowboys add beans to their chili?

The first recorded chili contest was conducted on Oct. 4, 1952, at the State Fair of Texas. But the contest rules stipulated no beans. Joe E. Cooper, author of a book on chili called, With or Without Beans, was named chairman of the contest.

“I believe there is likely no universal agreement on a single definition of chili,” Hancock said. “But the main reason we don’t allow beans in chili is that authentic Texas chili has always been defined as meat and sauce with peppers.” Beans are a dominant flavor and would distort the pure taste of chili, so they are not taken into consideration during the cook-off by our judges. ”.

Who do Texans hate beans in chili


Why does Texas not put beans in their chili?

If you go pretty much anywhere in Texas you will find chili ingredients simple and rarely differing: meat, sauce, peppers and spices. Carol Hancock, President and CEO of the International Chili Society, told Texas Living there is a specific reason why Texas chili contains no beans: it’s tradition.

Why are beans forbidden in chili?

No-beans side argue that beans distract your mouth from the beef and spices that chili is supposed to showcase. Texans in particular are likely to reject beans; in fact, the no-bean version is often referred to as Texas chili.

Did Cowboys put beans in chili?

In all likelihood, beans have long been a part of chili, even in Texas. And while purists will argue the point until they’re red in the face, that fight doesn’t hold sway with historians like Guerra. Cowboys mixed chili and beans on their tin plates according to the Chili Appreciation Society International.

Who originally put beans in chili?

But stories are spread that the beef was too valuable and was limited to be used as food on the cattle drive, so extra protein came from a pot of beans along side the chili pot. The cowboys then mixed the chili and beans together in a tin plate.

Leave a Comment