For many, pumpkin pie is a quintessential Thanksgiving dessert, evoking warm memories and cozy autumn vibes. But have you ever stopped to wonder what exactly goes into that delicious filling? While the name suggests a generous helping of pumpkin, the reality might surprise you.
The Shocking Truth: Your Pumpkin Pie Might Not Be Made with Pumpkin
While the label on your can of “pumpkin” proudly proclaims 100% pumpkin, the truth is a bit more nuanced. The FDA allows manufacturers to use a variety of squashes, including the Dickinson pumpkin, in their canned pumpkin.
The Dickinson pumpkin, though technically a pumpkin, differs significantly from the classic jack-o’-lantern variety. It’s a tan pumpkin with smooth skin, much larger than its field pumpkin counterpart. Its taste also differs, lacking the watery, stringy texture of the field pumpkin and offering a richer, sweeter flavor.
So, why the confusion? It boils down to the definition of “pumpkin.” The FDA defines canned pumpkin and canned squash broadly, allowing for the use of both pumpkins and squashes. This broad definition leaves room for interpretation, leading some manufacturers to use a mix of pumpkin and squash in their canned product.
Why Use Squash Instead of Pumpkin?
The use of squash in canned pumpkin is driven by several factors:
- Taste: The Dickinson pumpkin offers a superior flavor compared to the field pumpkin, making it ideal for the sweet and savory notes of pumpkin pie.
- Texture: The Dickinson pumpkin has a smoother texture, which translates to a more consistent and creamy pie filling.
- Availability: Dickinson pumpkins are more readily available and easier to cultivate than field pumpkins, making them a more cost-effective option for manufacturers.
Does It Matter if My Pumpkin Pie Isn’t Made with Pumpkin?
While the revelation that your pumpkin pie might not contain actual pumpkin might come as a surprise, it’s important to remember that the taste and quality of the pie remain the same. The Dickinson pumpkin, though technically a squash, delivers a flavor and texture that perfectly complements the classic pumpkin pie recipe.
So, the next time you enjoy a slice of pumpkin pie, remember that the filling might not be exactly what you expect. But rest assured, the deliciousness remains unchanged.
Additional Information:
- How to Make Pumpkin Puree from Fresh Pumpkins: If you’re feeling adventurous, you can try making your own pumpkin puree from fresh pumpkins. This allows you to control the ingredients and ensure you’re using actual pumpkin.
- Is Pumpkin a Fruit or Vegetable?: This age-old debate has no definitive answer. Botanically, pumpkin is a fruit, as it contains seeds and develops from the ovary of a flowering plant. However, from a culinary perspective, it’s often treated as a vegetable.
- The History of Pumpkin Pie: Pumpkin pie has a rich history, dating back to the 17th century when European settlers brought pumpkins to North America. The first pumpkin pie recipes appeared in American cookbooks in the early 1800s.
The revelation that pumpkin pie might not contain actual pumpkin might come as a surprise, but it’s important to remember that the taste and quality of the pie remain the same. The Dickinson pumpkin, though technically a squash, delivers a flavor and texture that perfectly complements the classic pumpkin pie recipe. So, the next time you enjoy a slice of pumpkin pie, remember that the filling might not be exactly what you expect. But rest assured, the deliciousness remains unchanged.
I chose my wife because, at a later age, I realized how much I loved pumpkin pie and that she made the best pumpkin pie in the entire world. It’s true that I enjoy spending time with her because she’s intelligent and kind, but the pumpkin pie was the real deal-breaker.
To get right down to the details of Libby’s “pumpkin,” they assert that they have created a unique strain of Cururbita pepo subsp. Pepo “Dickinson,” exclusive to their unique cans!
I have to use caution now because all I did was grow and mash the pumpkins. I had nothing to do with the actual pie making. However, the outcomes were evident as a bell, prompt, and consistent. and it wasn’t good.
We all decided, after voting, that the world’s greatest pumpkin pie is made with Libby’s canned pumpkin. Or should I say, Libby’s canned squash.
Subsequently, after considerable persuasion, the pies were taken from the oven, placed on a counter cooling rack, and then refrigerated for the final stage of conditioning. And then it was time for the tasting.
Pumpkins are a favorite fall symbol, the go-to Halloween decoration, and the centerpiece of countless pumpkin pies. Well, that last claim is untrue unless you use homemade pumpkin puree for your dessert.
Squash, beans, and maize were the “Three Sisters” that Native Americans grew most frequently, and they were essential staple foods for surviving the winter.
Today, pumpkins are grown on every continent except Antarctica, with India and China being some of the top producers. In the U.S., the Midwest claims the highest number of crops. Specifically, an area within 50 miles of Morton, IL produces most all of the pumpkins consumed in North America.
The traditional pumpkin has evolved into the large, smooth, orange one that comes to mind when we think of a “pumpkin patch” due to American farmers’ preference for larger, more robust pumpkins that are better suited for carving rather than cooking since the 1970s. ”.
We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you purchase through this page’s links, we might receive a small commission. Here’s our process.
Is Pumpkin Pie Really Better with EXPENSIVE Ingredients?
FAQ
Why is pumpkin pie called pumpkin pie?
Is pumpkin pie made from pumpkin guts?
Is pumpkin pie actually sweet potato?
What is pumpkin pie filling made of?