How Long Does Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Last in the Fridge?

Magnolia Bakery’s delectable banana pudding is a beloved treat, but how long can you savor its creamy goodness before it starts to lose its charm? To answer this pressing question, let’s delve into the insights provided by the bakery’s official FAQ page and the experiences shared by customers on Yelp.

Official Guidelines from Magnolia Bakery

Unfortunately, Magnolia Bakery’s FAQ page does not explicitly address the shelf life of their banana pudding. However, it does provide valuable information regarding the storage and handling of their products. According to the FAQ, all Magnolia Bakery products are made fresh daily and should be refrigerated upon purchase. This suggests that the banana pudding, like other perishable items, has a limited lifespan in the refrigerator.

Customer Feedback on Yelp

Yelp, the popular review platform, offers a wealth of customer experiences that shed light on the longevity of Magnolia Bakery’s banana pudding. Based on the collective wisdom of these reviews, a consensus emerges:

  • Best Enjoyed Fresh: Many reviewers emphasize that the banana pudding is at its peak of flavor and texture when consumed on the day of purchase. The pudding’s creamy custard and fluffy layers of banana slices harmonize perfectly, delivering an unforgettable taste experience.

  • Short Shelf Life in the Fridge: The majority of reviewers indicate that the banana pudding’s quality starts to decline after 1-2 days in the refrigerator. While it may still be edible, the bananas tend to brown, affecting the pudding’s overall appearance and taste.

  • Avoid Freezing: Some reviewers experimented with freezing the banana pudding, but the results were far from satisfactory. Freezing alters the pudding’s texture, making it icy and compromising its delicate flavors.

Recommended Storage and Consumption Guidelines

Based on the available information, here are some practical guidelines for storing and consuming Magnolia Bakery’s banana pudding:

  • Refrigerate Promptly: Upon purchase, refrigerate the banana pudding immediately to maintain its freshness.

  • Consume Within 1-2 Days: For optimal flavor and texture, enjoy the banana pudding within 1-2 days of purchase.

  • Avoid Freezing: Refrain from freezing the banana pudding, as it will negatively impact its quality.

Additional Tips for Extending Shelf Life

While the banana pudding’s shelf life is relatively short, there are a few additional tips you can follow to extend its freshness:

  • Store in an Airtight Container: Transfer the banana pudding to an airtight container to prevent exposure to air, which can accelerate browning.

  • Cover the Surface: If you’re not consuming the entire pudding at once, cover the exposed surface with plastic wrap to minimize oxidation.

  • Keep Refrigerated at All Times: Ensure the banana pudding remains refrigerated at all times to slow down the growth of bacteria and preserve its quality.

By following these guidelines, you can savor the delightful flavors of Magnolia Bakery’s banana pudding for as long as possible. Remember, the sooner you indulge, the better the experience!

Why this Recipe Works

Top Reasons You’ll Love this Recipe:

  • Super simple. I dare you to find a more delicious banana pudding recipe, even though this one starts with an instant pudding mix and is incredibly simple to make without the need for baking or stovetop cooking.
  • Total Crowd Pleaser. This pudding recipe is a crowd-pleaser and makes enough to feed a large group. It’s a great dessert for summer, but it’s also a great option for the holidays, potlucks, and family get-togethers.
  • The flavor is incredibly light, mousse-like, and creamy, with the ideal balance of banana slices and cakey vanilla wafers.

Despite being made famous in New York, this is the best southern banana pudding recipe! Banana pudding is a classic southern recipe that feels very summery, but we love making it for Thanksgiving and Christmas—it’s a great holiday dessert!

This recipe is authentic and comes directly from the cookbook of Magnolia Bakery. If you’d like to try something else from the cookbook, check out their red velvet banana pudding recipe!

Name Brands or Generic Brands: Either Work

The recipe specifically calls for Jell-O brand pudding mix and Nabisco Nilla Wafers, according to Magnolia Bakery’s instructions. I’ve used both name brands and generic store brands, and to be honest, I haven’t noticed a difference. You’ll still end up with delicious results!.

The Secret to Magnolia’s Famous Banana Pudding | The Best Restaurants in America | Food Network


How long does magnolia pudding last?

For orders placed on — Our world-famous Banana Pudding is made fresh daily, packed and shipped direct to you the same day. If you plan on enjoying it later, refrigerate Banana Pudding immediately and for up to 24 hours after delivery. We recommend never freezing our fresh Banana Pudding.

How long is banana pudding good for in the fridge?

Refrigerating it in a closed plastic container will keep it in good shape for at least 3-4 days. Freezing this yummy dessert for too long is another bad idea. Once you defrost your banana pudding, the taste and appearance won’t be the same.

Is Magnolia Bakery owned by Joanna Gaines?

Magnolia Silos expands as Chip and Johanna Gaines open the Magnolia Bakery. “Fixer Upper” took Waco by storm when it aired on HGTV in 2013. On July 27, Baylor alumni Chip and Joanna Gaines expanded their reach by adding Magnolia Bakery to the Magnolia Silos.

Why is Magnolia Bakery banana pudding famous?

Magnolia Bakery first rose to fame after appearing on “Sex and the City.” The NYC shop is famous for its banana pudding, and has shared the recipe for its iconic dessert. It requires just six ingredients, including vanilla wafers, vanilla pudding, and bananas.

How long does bread pudding last?

The best way to store bread pudding to stop it from returning to its stale bread state, you need to transfer it into an airtight container and put it in your fridge. You can keep it like this for up to 5 days. If you want to keep it longer, you will need to freeze it, after which it will be good for up to three months. More about that later.

How long does bread pudding last in the freezer?

In the Freezer (Up to Six Months) Opt for the freezer if you need to store your bread pudding for long periods. Bread pudding can last up to six months in the freezer. However, I recommend eating it up before the six-month mark. It will taste fresher the sooner you consume it.

Should bread pudding be refrigerated?

Always allow your bread pudding to cool down before storing it. Storing warm bread pudding will lead to excess moisture, which will ruin your bread pudding. You can let your bread pudding cool for up to two hours at room temperature before it must be stored in the refrigerator or freezer ( more on that later, folks ). 2.

How do you store leftover bread pudding?

The best way to store leftover bread pudding is to let it cool to room temperature and then keep it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 5 days. You can also freeze bread pudding for up to 3 months. If the bread pudding has sauce all over it (e.g custard), scrape as much as this off as you can before you store it.

Leave a Comment