I’ve told you before that my Aunt Mary is an incredible Italian cook. 99% of my extended family is from Ohio, so twice a year we’d pack up our maroon Aerostar with 2 adults, 3 kids, 5 pieces of luggage, and a cockapoo to visit everyone, and one of our favorite stops was Aunt Mary’s. She’d have a platter of Italian cookies waiting for us on the table, plus a vat of sausage and peppers bubbling in her homemade sauce on the stove. She’s been making them for as long as I remember, and the recipe was passed down from her mother, Rose, and likely Rose’s mother too!
I recently had a craving for Aunt Mary’s sausage and peppers that just wouldn’t quit then remembered once upon a time my Mom wrote down the recipe, so I took a look, and turns out, it is perfect for the crock pot! Crock Pot Sausage and Peppers is browned Italian sausages layered in a crock pot with seared onions, peppers, garlic, tomato sauce, and crushed tomatoes, then cooked low and slow all day long – until the sausages are nearly fall-apart tender and the sauce is like silk. I’m telling you, there is absolutely nothing better than the taste of this mouthwatering Italian dish!
Tips for Making Crock Pot Sausage and Peppers
- Technically you don’t need to brown the sausages before placing in the crock pot, but the caramelization gives the dish a delicious depth of flavor. Plus Aunt Mary always did it so we should too.
- This recipe freezes beautifully! Aunt Mary always sent us home with tupperwares full of sausage and peppers that we would freeze and ration out bit by bit to savor in between visits. To freeze, cool the sausage and peppers completely then transfer into Ziplock freezer bags and freeze flat. Thaw in the fridge overnight then reheat in a pot on the stove over low.
- We used to stuff Aunt Mary’s sausages into hard rolls smothered with sauce, but I now I serve my sausage and peppers on top of gluten-free pasta. Rolls, pasta, on a fork straight outta the crock pot – it’s not going to matter how you eat the sausages and peppers – just that you do!
Try this Fan Favorite Crock Pot Recipe
Start with 3lbs Sweet Italian Sausages. Sweet sausages aren’t actually sweet, rather they’re mild compared to the spiciness of hot Italian sausages. I used Johnsonville because they’re gluten-free, and delicious, but if you can find locally-made sausage that’s gluten-free (if you need it,) that’s going to give you the most authentic-tasting results.
Slice the sausages in half, or into thirds if they’re really long.
Next, brown the sausages in two or three batches, for 1-2 minutes on all four sides, or until golden brown. The sausages don’t need to be cooked through, just have a nice golden brown glow.
Transfer the sausages to a 6-quart crock pot.
In the fat leftover from the sausages add 2 sliced yellow onions, season with salt and pepper, then saute until they begin to soften and turn golden brown. Then, scoop them on top of the sausages in the crock pot.
Next add 2 large or 3 small sliced bell peppers (the color combo is up to you) then season with salt and pepper and saute until the peppers are crisp tender. Add 4 cloves minced garlic then saute for another minute, and then add the mixture on top of the onions in the crock pot.
Next add 1/4 teaspoon red chili pepper flakes (optional) plus a 28oz can tomato sauce, 28oz can crushed tomatoes, and 1/2 cup chicken broth. Mix everything up then cook on low for 5-6 hours, or until the sausages are very tender.
I MEAN. You HAVE to taste this!!
Saucy, so much flavor, yet incredibly simple, this is a recipe you will make again and again and again. It’s a huge crowd pleaser and, as my Aunt Mary knows, is great when company is coming over. People can eat whenever and however much they want, then keep coming back for more (which they definitely will.) Enjoy!
How to Cook Sausage in the Slow Cooker
Can you cook sausage in a slow cooker?
Serve slow-cooked sausage over brown rice, polenta tossed with whole-grain pasta or tucked into crusty whole-wheat rolls. Fresh or pre-cooked sausage can also be added to soups or stews prepared in the slow cooker. Dice or slice the sausage, brown it in a small amount of oil and add it to the soup ingredients before cooking.
Is sausage casing healthier option to eat?
Cellulose casings and some natural casings are perfectly fine to eat. Sausage casings are used to hold and shape filling inside so that it can be cooked. There are natural sausage casings and synthetic varieties, and most of them are edible. The healthiest way to cook them is by boiling or baking. Sausages provide high levels of vitamin B12 and iron, both of which are essential for healthy red blood cells and hemoglobin production.
What are the different types of sausage in a slow cooker?
Sausages come in various types, each with its distinctive taste and texture. Some popular variations include Italian sausage, bratwurst, chorizo, andouille, and breakfast sausages. Choosing the right sausage type will impact your slow-cooked dish’s overall flavor. What are the Different Ways to Cook Sausage in a Slow Cooker?
Can you put raw sausage in a crock pot?
Technically yes, you can put raw sausages in a Crock Pot for most slow cooker sausage recipes. The one downside though is that they won’t look anywhere near as appetizing, and have a bit less flavor without the browning. Unless you are in a crazy hurry, I’d recommend taking the few minutes it takes to brown your sausages in a skillet first.