If ever I were to go back to culinary graduate school and had to write a thesis, it would be about PUDDING. To the passing (American) Internet user, this seems a boring subject because what comes to mind is the gelatinous goo you can find in plastic cups in the refrigerator aisle of your local market (please note the calculated resistance to shamelessly mention Bill Cosby. Whoops!). But there are so many ways pudding is made, shared and eaten other than classic vanilla and chocolate. Frankly, the etymology of the word “pudding” is a rabbit hole I’m dying to go down. BUT I WON’T. Not yet, anyway, because the underpinnings of the word “pudding” is best served incrementally.
So why pudding? My passive rumination on pudding started with Yorkshire pudding. I heard a mention of it on the radio — something about how Yorkshire pudding didn’t actually originate in Yorkshire (public radio, of course). I didn’t hear the explanation, but a seed was planted. That seed sprouted when a Facebook friend who lives in England posted a photo of her first attempt at “Yorkshires.” They looked nothing like something that could be re-shaped and frozen into a pudding pop. They looked like dinner rolls.
I was aware that there is a marked difference between American pudding and English pudding, but this certainly didn’t match what I could imagine English flavored pudding to be. I imagined it to be something akin to black pudding (blood sausage) or mincemeat pie (meat mixed with fruit wrapped in pastry). So, WTF is Yorkshire pudding?
I sent my friend a photo of my feat. I told her it was savory and asked if she’d ever had it. Her response was “No – I generally stay away from anything pudding… Not really justified I just always read it as ‘mystery meat’.” Clearly, I am not the only person misled by the combination of the words Yorkshire + pudding.
The popover is an American version of Yorkshire pudding and similar batter puddings made in England since the 17th century, The oldest known reference to popovers dates to 1850. The first cookbook to print a recipe for popovers was in 1876.
Other Types of British Pudding
This form of “pudding” doesn’t even align with the British use of the word. According to Food Timeline, sausage puddings were derived from Roman customs, and by the 1800s the word “pudding” shifted to include sweet puddings that had somewhat of a cakey consistency and are, today, served as part of holiday traditions. But there’s not much of a connection between those puddings, Yorkshire pudding and the custard puddings Americans are accustomed to. There are so many questions!
So, sure, instead of a dinner roll, Yorkshire pudding balances out a great feast of meat and roasted root vegetables, but I don’t think it has to be savory. In fact, it makes a pretty awesome dessert/breakfast.
For now, my answer to all the questions is not to question anything and just improvise and experiment to create new traditions. This time around, I made cranberry syrup and added a tablespoon of the discarded cranberry pulp to the pudding batter and served the finished product with the syrup. Because it’s sweet, it’s called a Dutch Baby. This is certainly a toothsome and tart way for sweet and savory worlds to collide. I like it this way because you can use melted butter or vegetable oil to make it—having Sunday roast as often as I want popovers is just not reasonable.
My own Yorkshire pudding recipe adventure is as follows (adapted from The New York Times).
What is Yorkshire Pudding?
Basically, Yorkshire pudding is a popover. For some clarification, this is how I would describe Yorkshire pudding: somewhere between a dinner roll and quiche. Traditional Yorkshire pudding batter is egg, flour and milk made in a large rectangular pan (but you can use a Yorkshire pudding tin, a muffin pan or a popover pan) and cooked with hot meat drippings. It’s served with gravy alongside roast beef for a proper English Sunday roast dinner. Rather than schmaltz (rendered chicken fat — I used it because I happened to have saved a bit from another recipe), hot pan drippings collected from the roast beef or rib roast is used. The pudding batter was actually placed under the roast so that the fat cooks the batter as the meat was cooked to reduce waste. Popovers are individual Yorkshires made with butter rather than beef dripping.
In England they’re called Yorkshire Pudding, in America they’re called Dinner Rolls!
FAQ
What is American Yorkshire pudding?
Are Yorkshire puddings eaten in America?
How do you explain Yorkshire pudding to an American?
What do Americans call Yorkshire puddings?
The simple answer to what Americans call Yorkshire puddings is “popovers”. This popular American dish is often served with breakfast, drizzled with maple syrup or honey. While the American version may differ from the original Yorkshire pudding recipe, both dishes are delicious in their own right.
How did Yorkshire pudding get its name?
The origins of Yorkshire pudding go back to the 1700s, and there are several theories about how it got its name. Some say it was originally called “dripping pudding” because it was cooked in the fat from roast meat. Others believe it was named after a type of sausage called “pudding” that was popular in the region at the time.
What is the difference between Yorkshire pudding and American pudding?
Yorkshire pudding is a savory dish made from a simple batter of flour, eggs, and milk. It’s most often eaten as a side dish during a traditional Sunday roast beef dinner, with gravy poured over the top. Meanwhile, American pudding is a sweet, creamy dessert made from milk, sugar, and starch.
Are there different types of Yorkshire pudding?
Today, there are many variations of Yorkshire Pudding, including mini ones filled with savory ingredients and sweet ones drizzled with syrup. Despite its humble origins, Yorkshire Pudding remains a beloved dish that is steeped in tradition and history. Yorkshire Pudding vs. American Pudding: What’s the Difference?