Cocoa powder, a versatile ingredient derived from cocoa beans, is a staple in many kitchens. However, not all cocoa powders are created equal. Dutch-processed cocoa powder, while popular, undergoes a chemical treatment that alters its flavor and acidity. For those seeking a more natural cocoa experience, non-dutch processed cocoa powder offers a distinct flavor profile and culinary versatility. This guide explores the world of non-dutch processed cocoa powder, highlighting its benefits and providing recommendations for top brands.
Non-Dutch Processed Cocoa Powder: What Sets It Apart?
Unlike Dutch-processed cocoa powder, non-dutch processed cocoa powder undergoes minimal processing, preserving its natural acidity and flavor characteristics. This results in a cocoa powder that is:
-
Rich and Earthy: Non-dutch processed cocoa powder boasts a deep, robust flavor with hints of fruitiness and a pleasant acidity.
-
Higher in Antioxidants: The natural processing method retains more of the cocoa bean’s antioxidants, providing potential health benefits.
-
Versatile in Baking: Non-dutch processed cocoa powder can be used in a wide range of baking applications, from cakes and cookies to brownies and chocolate frosting. Its acidity balances sweetness and enhances flavor complexity.
Top Brands of Non-Dutch Processed Cocoa Powder
After extensive research and taste testing, we have compiled a list of the top non-dutch processed cocoa powder brands:
| Brand | Fat Content | Key Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| GERBS Natural Cocoa Powder | 22-24% | Rich, classic flavor with hints of dried fruit |
| Sunfood Superfoods Cacao Powder | 40% | Fruity and acidic, perfect for unique desserts |
| Penzeys Natural Cocoa Powder | N/A | Earthy and versatile, a favorite among bakers |
| Pure Natural Miracles Cacao Powder | 14% | Straightforward chocolate flavor, ideal for those transitioning from supermarket cocoa |
Benefits of Using Non-Dutch Processed Cocoa Powder
Incorporating non-dutch processed cocoa powder into your baking and cooking offers several advantages:
-
Enhanced Flavor: The natural acidity and flavor notes of non-dutch processed cocoa powder elevate the taste of desserts, adding depth and complexity.
-
Improved Texture: The higher fat content in some non-dutch processed cocoa powders contributes to a richer, more velvety texture in baked goods.
-
Healthier Alternative: The higher antioxidant content of non-dutch processed cocoa powder provides potential health benefits.
-
Supports Sustainable Farming: Choosing non-dutch processed cocoa powder supports cocoa farmers who prioritize natural and ethical farming practices.
For those seeking a more authentic and flavorful cocoa experience, non-dutch processed cocoa powder is an excellent choice. Its rich, earthy flavor, versatility in baking, and potential health benefits make it a valuable addition to any kitchen. By choosing top brands like GERBS, Sunfood Superfoods, Penzeys, and Pure Natural Miracles, you can elevate your desserts and support sustainable cocoa farming practices.
Straight to the Point
Our top picks for natural cocoa powders are those from Pure Natural Miracles and Sunfood Superfoods. You can read more of our recommendations below.
The Herbal Secrets brand has switched to a formula for cocoa powder since this guide’s initial publication, which no longer satisfies our requirements for a minimum amount of cocoa butter. Although references to that product may still exist in the comments and other parts of the website, we have removed it from our list.
Although I’m not usually into kitchen tricks, there are instances when a small tip can truly make all the difference in the world. It’s simple as this, if you’re a baker: Give up using low-fat cocoa powder in your baked goods. Because the chocolate that’s currently on your shelf, unless you’re a chocolate enthusiast, is low-fat.
However, if you upgrade your cocoa powder, your favorite cakes will taste suddenly richer and more aromatic, your cookies will be less crumbly and more flavorful, and your hot cocoa will be velvety and bolder all at once. I could go on forever (I haven’t even discussed fudge and ice cream), but I think you get the idea.
When it comes to chocolate, fat equals flavor, so don’t settle for inferior brands.
Understanding what cocoa powder is—the slightly acidic mass of dry matter left over after the oily cocoa butter is removed from cocoa beans that have been fermented and roasted for maximum flavor—is essential to understanding the answer. As a result, the final powder will differ based on the kind of cocoa bean used, its quality, the length of time it was fermented, the roasting temperature, and the amount of fat that was removed. This implies that different brands of natural cocoa powder will have different flavors, colors, and richness.
*The procedure is the same for cocoa made using the Dutch method, but an alkalizing agent is added to balance the cocoa’s inherent acidity.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__2018__03__20180413-natural-cocoa-powders-vicky-wasik-19-1500x1125-c1f68ec7f6fa4825bbafdf1065382137.jpg)
Because the FDA mandates that cocoa powder contain at least 2010% cocoa butter, most brands barely make it through with the bare minimum needed to meet that legal qualification. Since cocoa butter is pricey, the more that is extracted, the less money that is spent overall. However, the concentration of fibrous, starchy, and less aromatic cocoa solids increases with the amount of cocoa butter extracted; these qualities can give desserts a bland, chalky, and dry appearance.
While there is merit to their inventiveness, those were the only resources available to home cooks in the past. Fortunately, those days are long gone. Anyone can visit an online store and select from a variety of natural chocolates that provide a more optimal ratio of fat to flavor. However, sorting through that enormous amount of choices would require a full-time job, which is where I come in. I’ve reduced the selection to my top four natural cocoa powders after baking and sampling products from over a dozen brands.
These brands offered an amazing balance of flavor, color, richness, and aroma in a straightforward chocolate sheet cake. When contrasted with the identical cake prepared with reduced-fat cocoa powder, the disparity was nearly humorous. However, in contrast to one another, the cake’s competing flavors of butter, brown sugar, eggs, and vanilla nearly overshadowed each other’s subtleties. But in simpler recipes, like a simple chocolate pudding or a cup of hot cocoa, each cocoa powder’s unique flavor was evident. One cocoa in particular, in my opinion, stood out above the others, but your personal preferences may have you feel differently.
Think of this list as a starting point for exploring natural cocoa powder beyond what you’ll find in the grocery store and as a method to breathe new life into your favorite recipes without having to start from scratch.
The Best Natural Cocoa Powders
Given its fat content, which is between 22 and 24 percent, GERBS Natural Cocoa Powder is 100% appropriate.
It has a deep, earthy, and rich chocolate scent that is both classic and complex. It smells very chocolaty up front, but there’s an undertone that makes me think of dried figs. The scent that emanates from the bag and fills your nose with a cartoon-like atmosphere is what really caught my attention. Due to these characteristics, it is a versatile baking cocoa: it is fragrant and dark enough to pair with light and fruity desserts, yet it is bright enough to pair with intensely rich brownies and hot chocolate. After all the testing was completed, I decided to reorder this brand for myself because it’s a good all-around choice that will work well in any recipe that calls for natural cocoa.
What’s the Difference Between Dutched Processed Cocoa Powder and Natural Cocoa Powder?
FAQ
What cocoa is not Dutch processed?
How do I know if my cocoa powder is Dutch processed?
Is Nestle cocoa powder natural or Dutch processed?
Is Fry’s premium cocoa Dutch processed?
What is Dutch-processed cocoa powder?
Three Stand-Ins for This Baking Ingredient Dutch-processed cocoa powder (also known as Dutched chocolate, European-style cocoa, or alkalized cocoa) is an ingredient that may be called for in chocolate desserts, homemade ice cream, and hot chocolate recipes. It is unsweetened cocoa that has been treated with an alkali to make it pH neutral.
How is Dutch processed cocoa different from natural cocoa powder?
It’s naturally unsweetened, so recipes that use cocoa powder will also call for sugar to get the taste you’re looking for. How Is Dutch-Processed Cocoa Different? Natural cocoa powder is untreated, so it maintains its light brown color and is slightly acidic, with a pH between five and six.
What can I substitute for Dutch-processed cocoa powder?
But if a recipe calls for Dutch-processed cocoa powder and you are without it, there are substitutions you can make from basic pantry ingredients, such as unsweetened cocoa powder (natural cocoa powder), baking soda, and unsweetened baking chocolate.
What color is Dutch process cocoa?
Although all cocoa powders can vary in color from light reddish brown to a richer dark brown, the Dutch process gives the powder a noticeably darker hue. Dutch process cocoa has a smoother, more mellow flavor that’s often associated with earthy, woodsy notes.